FAILURE TO TIMELY TREAT A BROKEN BONE
Oct. 19, 2013
A frequent happening in Jails and Prisons is guards and medical staff fail to timely treat a broken bone or fracture.
Deliberate indifference is the standard under the Fourteenth Amendment, which applies to pretrial detainees or the Eighth Amendment, which applies to folks who are serving a sentence in prison or jail. In order to be successful in a deliberate indifference claim, you the inmate or detainee has to show two things: (1) a serious medical need; and (2) a subject intent to do nothing. Some courts explain the subjective intent as acknowledging the problem, understanding the risk and showing a conscious disregard to that risk.
A DELAY OF HOURS TO DAYS IS ENOUGH FOR A DELIBERATE INDIFFERENCE CLAIM
All Federal Appellate Courts have found that a broken bone - a fracture - is a serious medical need. So, the issue becomes whether the guard or healthcare provider, consciously disregarded the condition and the risk.
The Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals said that 6 hours for a broken foot is enough to allege a constitutional violation. Specifically, the court said:
A deliberate delay on the order of hours in providing care for a serious and painful broken foot is sufficient to state a constitutional claim.
Likewise, the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals, which looks at cases that involves Indiana has said that a broken hand is a serious medical need but a two hour delay in getting the patient x-rayed and casted is not deliberate indifference. Trial Courts in the Seventh Circuit have made statements like any reasonable officer should know that a broken bone needs to be casted. Others courts have said this:
A two day delay in treating a dislocated finger can rise to deliberate indifference.
A delay in access to medical care can be deliberate indifference.
Failing to time treat a broken collar bone can be deliberate indifference.
If you have any questions about bringing a deliberate indifference claim for failing to timely treat a broken bone, call Guy DiMartino Law immediately.