Close X

Blog

American Family Insurance files lawsuit trying to deny coverage in McGowan Shooting Case

Posted by Guy DiMartino | Oct 25, 2016 | 0 Comments

Michigan City personal injury lawyer comments on American Family Insurance's recent lawsuit trying to deny coverage in McGowan shooting case.

Img 0053 150x150

The McGowan shooting case has been in the newspaper for a while. A jury found McGowan guilty of killing Amanda Bach and sentenced him to 60 years. Bach's parents obviously distraught over the death of their daughter are seeking civil money damages against McGowan. A lawsuit was filed against McGowan and his father. The McGowans' home was insured through American Family Insurance. I'm sure American Family initially hired a lawyer to defend the civil lawsuit.

American Family has also hired another lawyer to file a case in federal court seeking a ruling from the federal court that it does not owe the McGowan's a duty to defend the civil lawsuit or indemnify (pay money to Bach's parents).

This Is How The Whole Thing Works

The language in the typical homeowner's insurance policy is broad and typically affords coverage for a variety of actions if a homeowner is negligent (careless). Almost all insurance companies have a list of exclusions in their policies. Many times the list of exclusions (the things the insurance company will not pay) is longer than the list of things the insurance will pay. Almost all insurance policies have  intentional acts and/or criminal exclusions. This exclusion typically says that the insurance will not pay money if its insured committed a criminal act. These policies make the distinct between negligence (carelessness) and crimes (intentional acts).

If you read the newspaper article in The Times, it sets out that Bach's parents' lawyer filed the civil lawsuit under a negligence theory. In essence, the complaint says that McGowan's dad was careless in leaving the gun in an area where his son was able to get the gun and commit the crime.

Based on the negligence theory set out in the complaint against McGowan and his dad, American Family had a duty to hire a lawyer for the McGowans in the civil matter. But now, American Family has filed a separate lawsuit in federal court, which is called a declaratory judgement action.

These lawsuits, a/k/a “dec actions” go something like this:

Court we are an insurance company and we are not sure of liabilities (responsibilities) under the insurance contract, so we are asking you to look at the facts of the case and the language in the contract, and tell us if we have a duty to defend the civil lawsuit and/or pay money. (paraphrased)

These dec actions are very common in cases where there are crimes or intentional torts (like battery). I do not know the exact language of American Family's policy or the specific facts that will be developed but we will see what happens.

Is The Insurance Company The Bad Guy?

Indiana personal injury and insurance law can be complex in situations like this. Some folks think that in such a tragic situation, the insurance company should just pay the insurance.  Other folks think that the insurance company should not be on the hook for the guy's actions.  What are your thoughts? What side of the coin are you on?

About the Author

Guy DiMartino

I have loved helping people in need for almost three decades.  It has been my privilege to serve people as their pastor, chiropractor, and lawyer.  The current focus of my legal practice and life’s passion is helping the seriously injured receive complete compensation for their injuries. I am a Florida Board Certified Civil Trial Attorney. What that really means is that I am no stranger to the courtroom.  I have successfully tried and handled serious cases in state and federal courts.  My backgrounds in both law and chiropractic medicine have given me a unique perspective, extensive knowledge, and wide experience to serve those I represent. For years as a chiropractic physician, I treated my patients to alleviate their pain and suffering. Now as their lawyer, I fight to bring them financial compensation for their pain and suffering. During my years of service, I have handled many traumatic injury cases ranging from the traumatic amputation of a limb to brain and spinal cord injury.  I consider it an honor to serve you and your family. When a person entrusts me and I accept to represent them, I don’t take that relationship and responsibility lightly. My approach is that we work as a team. We are partners and our goal is the best outcome for you and your family with the highest level of communication throughout. I am always available by phone or email to discuss my potential representation of your injury case. I handle cases throughout Florida. Education: National University of Health Sciences – BS (1984), DC (1986) Valparaiso University School of Law – JD, summa cum laude (1999) Bar Admissions: Florida (2000), Indiana (1999), Illinois (2000, expired); US District Courts of Appeals (11th Circuit, 7th Circuit); United States District Courts: Southern and Middle Districts of Florida; Northern and Southern Districts of Indiana; Northern and Central Districts of Illinois; and District of Colorado. Certification:  Civil Trial, Florida Bar Guy DiMartino on Google+ – Circle Guy on Google+ Guy DiMartino on Google+

Comments

There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Sample

Book icon 1

Guide To Indiana Car Accident Claims

Navigating The Mine Field

FREE DOWNLOAD

Sample

Book icon 2

Indiana Slip, Trip & Fall Claims

The Inside Story

FREE DOWNLOAD

Sample

Book icon 3

Understanding Indiana Truck Accidents

Frequently Asked Questions

FREE DOWNLOAD